Water Therapy for COPD Patients
Have you ever heard of using water therapy for COPD? Sometimes it's called hydrotherapy or aquatic therapy and it really is a thing. In fact, there have been a number of research studies done about water therapy for COPD. This post will inform you about hydrotherapy and how it may or may not benefit your respiratory status.
What is water therapy?
My first thought when someone mentioned water therapy for COPD was water-based exercise. That wasn't wrong, but it's not the only kind of water therapy that might be used. Hydrotherapy has actually taken many forms over the years to treat a variety of health conditions and diseases. It seems that water in its various forms and at different temperatures, both internally and externally, can have different effects on different parts of the body. That might make it a tool in healing, or at least relief from symptoms.1,2
- Water can store heat and energy
- Minerals and other substances can be dissolved in water
- Water in the form of ice can cool a body part
- You can inhale steam, a vaporized form of heated water, or immerse yourself in it
- Certain forms of water, such as a bath, shower or hot tub, can be soothing and relaxing
- Exercise in water is easier because there is less resistance to movement
Let's take a closer look at some of water's uses in natural medicine.
Superficial cold applications of water therapy
Have you ever seen professional or college athletes sitting in a tub of ice or ice water? That's a perfect example of superficial cold water therapy. Brr! Thankfully, it doesn't have to be that extreme. Simply sitting in a tub of cooler than room temperature water can be enough to produce reactions such as:2
- Slowing metabolism
- Lowered heart rate and blood pressure
- Decreasing swelling in the limbs
- Improved blood flow
- Calming muscle spasms and nerve hyperactivity
- Lowering of certain hormone levels, including renin, cortisol and aldosterone
- Mild numbing of the areas under water
Studies have shown that ice massage and application of ice packs have had similar results on the areas where they were applied.2
Superficial warm/hot application of hydrotherapy
Hydrotherapy may also involve being submerged in warm or hot water up to your neck. Some studies found that this type of water therapy can affect clotting and other blood factors.2 In warm enough temperatures (104 degrees), cardiac output can be improved for the duration of the immersion in the warm water. This, in turn, seemed to improve the use of oxygen in the body.2
Other "medicinal" uses of water for therapy
Some other ways water has been used as therapy include:2
Can water therapy do anything for people who have COPD?
Most of the studies that have been done on this subject looked at water-based exercise in regards to COPD, rather than the other forms of water therapy described above. However, one study in Germany did attempt to test the theories of a 19th-century naturopath, Sebastian Kneipp, who believed that applying water could have therapeutic benefits on many body systems, including the respiratory system.4
The researchers in the German study, reported in 2007, applied cold water compresses and washings to the upper body to see what effect it might have on certain respiratory factors, including:
- Lung function
- Blood gases
- Certain immune cells
- Maximal expiratory flow
- Quality of life
- Respiratory infections
Results of the study
The researchers found that this therapy did improve immune system function and lowered the risk of respiratory infections, a common cause of COPD exacerbations. It also had a positive effect on the quality of life. However, this study was a very small sample size (20 patients), so these results may or may not be valid. I couldn't find any more recent studies validating this one.
Water-based exercise has more promising benefits
On the other hand, a few more studies have been done that looked at whether COPD patients could benefit from water-based exercise. These studies seem based mainly on the premise that, as COPD is most common in older adults, they would likely have other health challenges as well, including:5
- Bone, joint and muscle deformities or weaknesses
- Cerebrovascular disease, resulting in decreased blood flow to the brain
Land-based exercise is often recommended for people with COPD and is part of every traditional pulmonary rehab program. It is known to improve exercise capacity and quality of life.6 But when the person with COPD also has one or more of the issues mentioned above, land-based exercise might be difficult or not even possible.
So researchers have studied whether moving exercise to the water, such as in a pool, might be easier to tolerate and have greater benefits. One study, done in Australia and reported in the European Respiratory Journal,looked at the effect of water-based exercise on:5
- Exercise capacity
- Health-related quality of life
- Respiratory muscle strength
They found that water exercise was effective in all aspects. However, this study size was again quite small (53 participants). So the researchers expanded their research by doing a review of similar studies.6 They found 5 studies overall with 176 participants; only 71 of those participated in water-based exercise programs.
The result of their review was that there do appear to be at least short-term benefits in exercise capacity and some quality of life factors. However, there is not enough quality evidence proving long-term benefits. Certainly, we need more extensive research to be sure.
Most water therapy is safe
So, if you have COPD, should you be considering some sort of water-based therapy? The bottom line is that most water therapy, when used correctly and with your health care team's OK, is safe. So, chances are, there's no harm in trying. And water-based exercise seems to have the most promise and is in line with the general goals of pulmonary rehabilitation.
If you'd like to try it, there are a number of types of water-based exercise you might try. You could join your local health club and start swimming or walking laps in their pool. Some health clubs offer specific aqua exercise programs, such as water aerobics or Aqua Zumba. There are even water-based Pilates, yoga and tai chi programs available in some areas.
You should never begin an exercise program without your health care team's blessing. But once you have that, give it a try. You just might like it, and you might feel better for it as well!
Have you ever had to educate a doctor?